Today’s executives have access to more tools, information, resources, and opportunities than ever before. But they’re also navigating enormous uncertainty as AI changes how companies operate and geopolitical shifts reshape global markets. Amid widespread change, how can leaders find a stable footing and build strategies that create value?
The McKinsey coauthors of the forthcoming book Strategy and Value: The Four Foundations That Drive Long-Term Performance tackled those questions in a recent McKinsey Live event. Senior Partner Andy West, Distinguished Expert Whitney Zimmerman, and Partner Emeritus and Senior Adviser Tim Koller discussed the impact of uncertainty on strategic decisions, the declining quality of company strategies, and how leaders can apply four foundational principles to tough strategy decisions.
Uncertainty is on the rise
Perceived uncertainty has been rising for 35 years, according to the World Uncertainty Index, and the past year has seen a meaningful spike. At the same time, executives’ priorities are becoming more complex. For example, the frequency with which themes such as AI, transformation, and environmental, social, and governance (ESG) are discussed in earnings calls—a proxy for business complexity—has grown by 31 percentage points over the past decade. Some companies treat these challenging dynamics as opportunities, but many leaders have difficulty focusing on the decisions that matter most.
The quality of strategies is declining
This uncertainty has negative consequences for strategy setting. In fact, McKinsey research finds that the quality of strategies has fallen by 40 percent over the past 15 years despite the profusion of tools, data, and information. Moreover, the gap in average annual economic profit between the top and bottom quintiles rose from about $755 million in 2000–04 to about $2.4 billion in 2020–24, while the middle three quintiles remained broadly flat.
But having good ideas is only part of the challenge. Leaders also need to act on those ideas, make clear trade-offs, and reallocate resources toward the opportunities that will create the most value even in the face of uncertainty.
Four foundations can support value creation in strategy
Against this challenging backdrop, how can leaders approach strategy in a way that drives long-term performance? Four enduring foundational principles can increase the chances that a strategy will create value:
- Harness market attractiveness. Understand why a market is worth playing in and use that to guide your decisions about how and where to invest.
- Build real competitive advantage. Be clear about what your company can do that competitors cannot readily match: the strengths that matter and allow you to earn more than your fair share of a given market.
- Target ROIC and growth. Connect strategic choices to the cash flows and returns they should generate. Value is driven by cash flows, which are driven by ROIC and growth.
- Manage for the long term. Commit capital, talent, and management attention over the long haul so your choices have time to pay off. A long-term management approach is always warranted and important.
In strategy, three disciplines matter
Making good strategic choices requires bridging theory and practice, and it isn’t easy. How can leadership teams address that challenge? McKinsey research suggests that three disciplines are critical:
- Build a shared reality. Establish agreement on strategic challenges, the direction of the business, who the customer is, and which market dynamics matter.
- Debate effectively. This is where leaders bring empathy and openness to problems. Consider different points of view, question assumptions, welcome informed disagreement, give everyone a voice, and limit debate to the things that matter.
- Hold strategy to a high bar. To mobilize your strategy, create a coherent underlying thesis and make clear choices. It’s also important to know how to identify the things that aren’t creating value and stop doing them.




