Although construction is one of the world’s largest ecosystems,1 it typically performs with slim margins (approximately 5.0 percent earnings before interest and taxes) and low productivity improvements (an average productivity growth of 1.0 percent per annum for the past 20 years versus about 2.8 percent for the total economy2). Faced with additional pressure from recent disruptions, including the COVID-19 pandemic, the war in Ukraine, and overall slowdown in new building projects, construction companies are doubling down on procurement as a key driver of improving profitability and navigating uncertainty.
In addition, construction has a major role to play in achieving global sustainability goals. As an industry, construction is directly responsible for approximately 40 percent of CO2 emissions and indirectly responsible for 25 percent of all greenhouse-gas (GHG) emissions.3 The majority of these emissions are Scope 3, meaning they originate either with suppliers or from using and operating the built environment.
Keeping these points in mind, optimizing procurement can help accelerate construction’s decarbonization efforts and become a source of competitive advantage in the years to come. In this article, we outline how procurement can deliver on its dual mission of improving profitability and driving decarbonization, and we recommend actions for chief procurement officers (CPOs) and other leaders across the value chain who want to take a proactive stance as the industry transitions.
The procurement opportunity in construction
Procurement plays an important role in construction, typically accounting for 40 to 70 percent of a company’s total spending, and industry executives see the function as a trusted business partner.4 Recently, construction companies have doubled down on procurement to better navigate uncertainty.
Recent McKinsey research highlights how the pandemic and the war in Ukraine have had a significant impact on commodity prices and supply chains.5 This can already be seen in rising inflation around the world. For example, in 2022, most countries grappled with year-over-year inflation of more than 5 percent. And although the duration and impact of today’s rates of inflation are unknown, they are certain to put additional pressure on construction’s profitability.6
Despite the significant margin impact of procurement, the construction industry is not keeping up with other industries when it comes to implementing best practices (exhibit). This is partially explained by external challenges—such as limited control over project specifications and complex, fragmented supply chains—and internal challenges such as decentralized project-by-project mindsets.
Some construction companies have been able to overcome these challenges and develop group- or nationwide sourcing strategies that capture significant savings potential. Those with best-in-class procurement practices actively contribute to improving their companies’ financial results, with margins that are sometimes five to ten percentage points higher than those of procurement laggards.7 And many construction CPOs believe that consistently applying best-in-class procurement practices can generate savings of as much as 12 percent for their companies (see appendix, “Evergreen procurement: What procurement leaders in construction do differently”).8
The dual mission of procurement: A strategic era for CPOs in construction
In addition to playing a key role in improving profitability in volatile and inflationary times, procurement will likely play an even greater role in decarbonizing construction. Given that 90 percent of the emissions from construction companies are Scope 3,9 and that procurement is the main interface with the construction value chain, it’s fair to say that CPOs will be in the driver’s seat for reducing the CO2 footprint of construction projects. Engineers and architects can help upstream by making changes in design, specifications, and materials procurement that complement downstream efforts. This can help elevate the role of the CPO in construction companies beyond a trusted business partner and toward a more strategic function, as seen in the automotive industry.10
The following near-term levers can help procurement play a key role along the value chain:
- Create transparency for the CO2 footprint. Managing CO2 targets will soon be as relevant as managing project budgets. Given the lack of standardized and widely accepted metrics for measuring emissions across the construction value chain, procurement experts will likely need to develop views of the full life cycle and provide estimates of emissions in material sourcing for suppliers—for example, assessing impact from sustainable versus nonsustainable materials or CO2 cleansheets.
- Gain a granular perspective on materials and suppliers. Knowing how materials and suppliers differ in cost and CO2 emissions will become increasingly important for procurement. Creating a granular view of the value chain can include the material category and supplier and individual assets, such as the fuel or energy mix, raw materials, production processes, and logistics. This can enable informed sourcing decisions to effectively embed sustainability in the procurement process. On this point, procurement experts can work with suppliers to gather relevant inputs, such as volume, composition, energy efficiency, and fuel consumption, and complement their findings with expert research on emissions factors. In today’s volatile environment, procurement teams can also develop a resilience toolbox along their supply base by refreshing category strategies and revisiting the risk operating model. This can be supported by a central nerve center, such as a spending control tower or a live resilience dashboard.
- Help manage trade-offs. Procurement teams can work hand in hand with engineering and project management teams to make the right trade-offs, further establishing themselves as key thought partners rather than a delivery function. The role of value engineering in construction will become even more relevant as companies seek to standardize models and components, improve and optimize designs, and push for lower-cost materials. Procurement teams will need to adjust the materials mix by prioritizing eco-friendly or low-emissions solutions and complementing them with the right set of tools to act as relevant advisers for value engineering in trade-offs of design cost versus CO2 emissions. For example, an engineering, procurement, and construction player in oil and gas developed a tool and cross-functional processes to assess how different suppliers or materials may affect the construction process and plan. In particular, this tool can help assess when “green products” will yield premiums versus traditional solutions—which 65 percent of developers and contractors say is important.11
Longer-term or strategic levers will center on securing access to green materials. Anticipating where future shortages of materials will occur and securing access to supply in the long term will require strategic decision making and demand forecasting far beyond current project pipelines. Increasing integration with suppliers—via supplier development, demand, and capacity planning, as well as helping suppliers decarbonize their energy use—will continue to be relevant, but it will likely not suffice. The level of scarcity of certain materials may require construction companies to invest in, fully acquire, or build new suppliers to secure access, as the auto industry had to do when automotive OEMs invested in green-steel start-ups in Europe and the United States.12
The procurement function will need to excel in its dual mission of improving profitability in a volatile environment and meeting sustainability targets.
Construction companies that are able to build such expertise and capabilities can lead in the green transition and position themselves to become attractive partners to developers and project owners. However, this will require procurement teams to act along three dimensions:
- Talent and expertise. Decarbonizing the construction of a building or structure is often highly complicated, with a nearly endless number of decisions and alternatives. As a result, it requires leading construction companies to build, train, and attract new expertise. To be a partner to forward-leaning project owners, developers, and other specifiers, leading construction companies need the expertise to guide and recommend trade-offs between alternative materials and technologies, weigh design simplifications against impact on function and value, and assess risks and evaluate unproven approaches. New expert roles should be not only embedded in the procurement organization but also closely integrated with engineering and design functions and project teams.
- Roles and mandates. To ensure this expertise is fully leveraged to meet sustainability targets, construction companies can review roles and mandates. CPOs and procurement leaders should get involved in projects early, such as during the tendering phase, and act as key partners and decision makers on material and supplier selection. This entails providing specific recommendations or alternatives to optimize trade-offs between profitability and sustainability targets tailored to each category and each project, as well as securing access to scarce resources by pursuing M&A opportunities (among other strategies).
- Data and market intelligence. As previously mentioned, procurement teams will need a more granular perspective on materials and suppliers, which requires access to additional data as well as the right tools and dashboards to support decision-making processes. In the coming years, the construction and building materials industry is likely to progress rapidly and mature in production processes, alternative materials, new technologies, and other ways to decarbonize. During this time, data might not be readily available. To make informed decisions and to secure certifications, procurement teams can collect reliable information and data on alternatives, which may require building databases, conducting research, and even performing tests. Teams can also leverage available information such as environmental product declarations and life cycle assessments. However, this information should be complemented by highly granular information gathered in partnership with suppliers, such as the CO2 footprints of certain materials or the manufacturer, plant, production line, and energy mix of specific production batches. Regarding new digital tools, teams can use dashboards similar to those used to manage customer relationships to collect, display, and interpret data ranging from emissions at the asset level to logistics costs and emissions, and use these data to support trade-off decisions tailored to each project’s defined targets.
As the main interface with the construction value chain, the procurement function will need to excel in its dual mission of improving profitability in a volatile environment and meeting sustainability targets. In doing so, procurement will be elevated to new heights as it emerges as a strategic function. CPOs who act now can help their companies lead the sustainability transition and position themselves as attractive partners to leading developers in the future.
Download the article and the appendix here.