Dominic Barton and Kito de
Boer
July 4, 2006
The Silk Road between the Middle East and Asia was until
the 13th century the world's most important trade route. After 700 years during
which merchants looked instead to Europe and the Americas, trade and investment
is once again flowing between these regions.
While Asia's thirst for Middle Eastern oil is well
understood, less often recognised is the increasing flow of direct and portfolio
investment. Thus Sheikh Mohammed bin Rashid al-Maktoum, the ruler of Dubai, used
a recent state visit to Pakistan to announce a multi-billion dollar package of
infrastructure, property and other investments. Prominent Saudi investors, led
by Prince Alwaleed bin Talal, are paying $2bn for a stake in China's second
largest state-owned bank. Bahrain's Gulf Finance House wants to invest up to
$1bn in Singapore's financial, health, tourism and leisure industries.
The traffic along the New Silk Road is not one way. An
alliance of seven companies known as the Singapore Specialist Construction
Consortium is pursuing Middle Eastern construction projects. Dubai is already
home to Chinamex Mart, a mini-city of Chinese companies distributing their
products throughout the region. In the technology sector, Samsung Electronics is
among Asian companies intensively cultivating Middle Eastern markets.
From a macroeconomic perspective, these developments
make perfect sense. In the five years to 2010, Asia is likely to require about
$1,000bn of foreign direct investment, with China alone consuming more than half
of that total. With oil prices riding high, meanwhile, Gulf states' investors
and companies have money to invest.
Recent interviews with more than a dozen Gulf investors,
who collectively control more than $300bn in assets, revealed that they are set
to shift their portfolio asset allocation toward Asia by 10-30 per cent. We
believe that up to $250bn will be available for investment in Asia over the next
five years. While the west would remain Asia's dominant source of investment,
this would represent an important shift in the pattern of global capital
flows.
Such portfolio rebalancing would allow Gulf investors to
benefit not only from Asia's strong internal growth but also from the emergence
on the world stage of Asian companies such as Haier, Lenovo, Petronas, Ranbaxy,
Samsung, Sterlite and Huawei. Another straw in the wind: Etisalat, a telecoms
group located in the United Arab Emirates, earlier this year acquired a
controlling stake in Pakistan Telecommunications Company for $2.6bn.
These Asian companies, many of them low-cost
competitors, in turn are well positioned to help meet the Gulf's massive
infrastructure needs. Electricity, highway, telecoms, water and other
infrastructure projects - along with agriculture, education, healthcare and
information technology initiatives - will consume more than $500bn over the next
five years.
The two regions have more in common than a desire for
trade and investment. Commercial links between the Gulf states and Asia should
go hand in hand with growth of Islamic banking in accordance with Sharia, which
prohibits the use of interest or speculation. Today, almost 20 per cent of
private investors in the Gulf say they are prepared to accept lower than
conventional market returns or service for full Sharia compliance. Investors
with similar attitudes live in parts of Asia such as Indonesia, Malaysia and
even China.
This helps explain why Gulf banks such as Al Rajhi Bank
and Kuwait Finance House have launched - or are about to launch - operations in
Malaysia, why Malaysian and Singaporean banks are eyeing opportunities to
facilitate capital flows between the regions and why Kuwait Finance House has
secured a mandate to structure the first Islamic bond (Sukook) in China.
To be sure, these are still early days for the New Silk
Road. There remains a lot more opportunity than activity. It is difficult for
companies and investors to shake long-held habits of focusing on western
markets, investing in western companies and purchasing western equities and
bonds.
Both regions need to improve mutual understanding
through educational and political exchanges. Governments also need to move
beyond symbolic events such as state visits to create a more hospitable
investment climate.
This means dismantling barriers to competition, such as
restrictive licensing rules and product market regulations. It means boosting
the transparency of financial reporting, creating more effective markets for
corporate control and improved corporate governance. Such measures would enhance
the attractiveness of both regions and the efficiency of capital allocation.
The good news is that there are signs of progress. In
addition to Dubai and Bahrain (historically the financial capital of the Gulf
region), Saudi Arabia recently decided to allow foreigners to invest directly in
Saudi companies through the stock exchange. Similarly, the Gulf Co-operation
Council is strengthening capital markets through modern laws and exchanges.
Improving capital markets and corporate governance in
Asia and the Gulf states would be valuable under any circumstances. At a time
when companies and investors are just starting to build a New Silk Road, the
need for reform has never been greater.
Dominic Barton is a director in
McKinsey's Shanghai office; Kito de Boer is a director in Dubai.
This article was originally published in the Financial Times.