By Martin Hirt
and Gordon Orr
September 15, 2006
While multinational corporations continue to expand in mainland China,
mainland companies are going overseas. They are making acquisitions and
forming alliances to win access to raw materials, technology and consumer
brands - as well as new markets.
Some skeptics question whether mainland businesses can succeed in their forays
into western markets. But they do have some advantages - including cheap
financing from state-owned banks - in competing with
western bidders. They also, often, are in a good position to cut costs at
acquired companies, if they can shift the manufacturing to the mainland.
Against these pluses are a number of challenges. Turning around troubled assets is
tough - even for experienced acquirers with first-class skills in
mergers and acquisitions and deep local knowledge; mainland companies lack both.
When we talk to seasoned mainland business leaders, the question often at
the top of their minds is how to integrate the management of an acquired company
- to bridge the geographical and cultural gaps between it and the
Chinese corporate centre. Mastering integration is a prerequisite for success:
much of the value in many acquisitions comes from combining the mainland's cost
advantage with the brand, technology and other assets of a western business.
In our experience, several steps are essential for
ensuring that mainland companies succeed in mergers and acquisitions. They all
force the acquirer to prepare for the task long before the deal is done, and to
move quickly and decisively to take advantage of the brief window of time when
employees of acquired companies expect change. Lenovo started planning
systematically to integrate IBM's personal computer business almost a year
before completing the deal. But others have made acquisitions without preparing
for "the day after".
Keeping the entire, acquired management team in place
sends a strong signal that the order of the day is business as usual, and that
major changes should not be expected. The answer, in many cases, is to bring in
experienced local managers, and sometimes a new chief executive, from
outside.
Bridging the gap between a mainland company and an
overseas business that it acquires is crucial, but it doesn't happen naturally:
ties must be encouraged. One effective approach is to dispatch "connectors":
experienced Chinese managers, with good language skills, who join overseas
operations to help them communicate with headquarters.
Management tasks are sometimes fragmented between the mainland headquarters and overseas
operations. In such cases, failure is preordained. The answer is
to make one manager - in China or abroad - directly
accountable, with end-to-end responsibility for introducing new products and
fulfilling orders. Cultural gaps in management style and practice might never be
fully overcome. They must be managed to blend, and make the most of, the skills
on both sides.
Finally, the use of top-quality, simultaneous translation
services might seem a trivial matter, but it isn't. Today, executive assistants
often take on the role of translator in business meetings. Such "sequential"
translation often makes people feel disconnected: simultaneous translation (into
earphones) is far better.
Mainland business leaders have taken their first steps to
creating global enterprises, which for many have proved to be more challenging
than anticipated. They must now take in the lessons from these initial struggles
and build the managerial and operational skills required for lasting success in
international markets.
Download the article (PDF - 540 KB)
Martin Hirt heads McKinsey &
Company's high tech and telecoms practice in Greater China; Gordon Orr leads
their strategy practice in Asia.
This article was originally published in the South China Morning Post.